Xabi Alonso’s spell at Real Madrid wasn’t the catastrophe some are painting it as. He posted the club’s best win percentage in a decade, only to be undone by board politics, power plays and a superstar who never fully bought in. The ending was ugly, but the work wasn’t. And that’s precisely why it stands out, because plenty of other legends really did go back to their old clubs and set the place on fire for all the wrong reasons.
So here’s a look at the homecomings that weren’t just disappointing… they were genuinely disastrous.
Xabi Alonso at Real Madrid
July 2025 – January 2026
On paper, this should’ve been the fairytale. A Champions League‑winning midfielder returning as the most sought‑after coach in Europe, after an unbeaten Bundesliga season in 2023/24 and a tactical glow‑up that turned Bayer Leverkusen into a machine. And for a while, it looked like he’d cracked it, the highest win percentage of any Madrid manager in a decade is not the CV of a man out of his depth.
But Madrid is Madrid. Board politics, power plays, and a superstar who never fully bought into the project turned a promising reign into a messy exit. Xabi Alonso didn’t implode, the club did what the club always does when the internal temperature rises. Still, the ending was chaotic enough to earn him a place on this list, if only as the calm before the real disasters begin.
Ronald Koeman at Barcelona
August 2020 – October 2021
If Alonso’s exit was messy but understandable, Koeman’s Barcelona stint was pure, unfiltered Mayhem. A club legend who scored the biggest goal in Barça’s history returned expecting to steady the ship, instead, he walked straight into a burning building and somehow managed to fan the flames.
The football was disjointed, the squad never bought into his ideas, and the results lurched from bad to worse. Fans turned, the media turned, and even the board, who were already a circus, eventually decided they’d seen enough. By the end, Koeman looked like a man begging to be put out of his misery, and Barcelona obliged.
A legendary player, yes. A successful homecoming? Not even close.
Frank Lampard at Chelsea
July 2019 – January 2021 & April – June 2023
Not one, but two questionable reigns. Lampard’s return to Chelsea started with promise, top four during a transfer ban, academy kids thriving, but the mood soured fast. Results dipped, performances flattened, and he clashed with senior management over transfer policy before being shown the door.
Then came the sequel, and it was genuinely grim. A 9% win rate turned his second stint into blood‑curdling viewing, with Chelsea looking lifeless, lost and completely unrecognisable. For a club legend, it wasn’t a homecoming, it was a legacy‑risking nightmare.
Alan Shearer at Newcastle
April – May 2009
If there’s one man Newcastle fans would follow into a burning building, it’s Alan Shearer. The club’s greatest goalscorer, a local hero, a living monument on Tyneside. So when he returned in 2009 to save them from relegation, it felt like destiny, the ultimate homecoming.
Instead, it was a nightmare.
Shearer took over with eight games to go and won just one of them. Newcastle slid into the Championship, the squad looked broken, and the fairytale turned into a grim reality check. It wasn’t all his fault, the club had been run into the ground, but the outcome was brutal. The legend came home to rescue the club he loved, and ended up overseeing one of its darkest modern moments.
A hero forever, but as a manager, his homecoming was pure heartbreak.
Jürgen Klinsmann at Bayern Munich
July 2008 – April 2009
Bayern bringing back Jürgen Klinsmann sounded like a prestige move: a club icon, a World Cup‑winning striker, a man with grand ideas about modernising the place. What they got instead was one of the most baffling managerial stints the club has ever seen.
First there were the Buddhas. Klinsmann had them installed around the training ground as part of a “mindfulness” overhaul that left players confused, the board utterly bewildered and tabloids crying out for more. The football was disjointed, the players hated the training methods, and the results were so poor that Bayern, yes, Bayern, ended up losing the Bundesliga to Wolfsburg. By April, the hierarchy had seen enough and cut the experiment short before the season even finished.
Filippo Inzaghi at AC Milan
June 2014 – June 2015
Pippo Inzaghi returning to AC Milan should’ve been a romantic reunion: a Champions League hero, a poacher turned prodigal son, stepping into the dugout to revive a fading giant. Instead, it was a brutal reminder that elite goalscorers don’t automatically become elite managers.
Milan were a mess under him — tactically confused, painfully flat, and drifting further away from the top of Serie A with every passing week. Inzaghi looked out of his depth almost immediately, and the results reflected it: a mid‑table finish, a fanbase losing patience, and a club desperate to hit the reset button.
For a striker who lived off instinct, his managerial homecoming had none. It was a reunion built on nostalgia that delivered nothing but disappointment.
Andrea Pirlo at Juventus
August 2020 – May 2021
Another majestic Italian legend for the list. Juventus handed Pirlo the job with zero experience, hoping his elegance on the pitch would translate to the dugout. Instead, his team looked slow, predictable and miles off the dominance the club expected. They scraped into the top four on the final day, crashed out of Europe early, and the whole experiment lasted just one season. A legendary player, but his return as manager never got close to matching the aura.
Football loves a romantic return, but this list shows how often nostalgia turns toxic. Clubs chase sentiment, legends chase legacy, and everyone ends up learning the same lesson: coming home is easy, succeeding there is brutal. In the end, even the greatest icons can find out the hard way that the past is a dangerous place to try and relive.
The Top 10 FA Cup Upsets of All Time: Glory, Agony and Pure Football Madness
FA Cup upsets are synonymous with English football. The world’s oldest cup competition has always been English football’s great leveller,…
16 Legendary Transfers: The Most Influential Deadline Day Squad Ever
It’s one of the most popular days in the sporting calendar. Deadline Day transfers have produced some of football’s most…
AFCON 2025: Morocco’s World Cup Dry Run
Stepping into Morocco during AFCON 2025, one thing was immediately clear: this was no ordinary tournament. This was a high-stakes…