Antoine Semenyo has made a sensational start to his Manchester City career, and could well be the final piece of the puzzle that helps deliver an astonishing quadruple this season. It’s early days, but the impact has been immediate: goals, assists, energy, tactical flexibility and that unmistakable sense that City have once again found a player who fits their system like he was grown in a lab under the Etihad.
January signings aren’t supposed to be this influential. The winter window is usually for patch‑ups, short‑term fixes, and mild panic. But every so often, a club makes a move that doesn’t just improve the squad, it changes the trajectory of the entire team.
Here, For Foot Sake looks at ten of the most transformational January signings in football history.
Virgil van Dijk – Southampton to Liverpool (2018)
The most expensive defender in the world at the time, and somehow still a bargain. Van Dijk didn’t just improve Liverpool, he redefined them. Overnight, the chaos disappeared. The high line made sense. The press had a safety net. The goalkeeper suddenly looked world‑class. Within 18 months, Liverpool had won the Champions League. Within two years, they had their first league title in 30 years. Two Premier Leagues, a Champions League and a Ballon d’Or runner‑up finish later, it’s hard to argue against Van Dijk being the greatest January signing of all time.
Bruno Guimarães – Lyon to Newcastle United (2022)
The signing that announced Newcastle’s new era. Guimarães didn’t just raise the level, he raised the standards. His arrival coincided with a cultural shift: belief, ambition and a style of football that finally matched the club’s size. He helped deliver Newcastle’s first major trophy in decades and became the heartbeat of a side transitioning from relegation candidates to European contenders. A transformational player in every sense.
Riyad Mahrez – Le Havre to Leicester City (2014)
A £400k signing who became a Premier League champion, PFA Player of the Year, and one of the most elegant wingers the league has ever seen. Mahrez didn’t just transform Leicester, he transformed the league. His dribbling, his unpredictability, his left foot… he was the creative spark behind the greatest underdog story in modern football. From a January punt to a global superstar. That’s the magic of the window.
Philippe Coutinho – Inter Milan to Liverpool (2013)
January signings don’t get much more impactful than this. Signed for £8.5m, became the creative heartbeat of Liverpool, and was later sold for a fee so large it effectively funded the construction of a Champions League‑winning team. Coutinho’s impact was twofold: he was brilliant on the pitch AND his sale financed Van Dijk and Alisson. Few transfers have ever shaped a club’s future so dramatically.
Seamus Coleman – Sligo Rovers to Everton (2009)
£60,000. Sixty thousand. For over a decade, Coleman was one of the Premier League’s most consistent full‑backs, a leader, a captain and a symbol of Everton’s identity. In an era of inflated fees, this remains one of the greatest bargains in football history, and a reminder that transformational signings don’t always come with big price tags.
Marcelo – Fluminense to Real Madrid (2007)
An £8m January signing who went on to become one of the greatest left‑backs of all time. Marcelo didn’t just transform Real Madrid, he helped define an era. His partnership with Cristiano Ronaldo, his attacking brilliance, his Champions League pedigree… he became a symbol of the club’s modern dominance. The club’s most decorated player; Five Champions Leagues, countless trophies and a legacy that will be almost impossible to replicate.
Christophe Dugarry – Bordeaux to Birmingham City (2003)
A World Cup winner arriving at St Andrew’s felt surreal at the time, and still does. Dugarry’s loan spell was short, chaotic and utterly unforgettable. He scored crucial goals, lifted the entire squad and almost single‑handedly kept Birmingham in the Premier League. Not every transformational signing has to be long‑term. Sometimes, it’s about impact in the moment, and Dugarry’s was enormous.
Nemanja Vidić – Spartak Moscow to Manchester United (2006)
A £7m signing who became one of the most dominant centre‑backs the Premier League has ever seen.
Vidić transformed United’s defence, formed an iconic partnership with Rio Ferdinand, and helped deliver multiple league titles and a Champions League. He was tough, fearless, and utterly relentless, the kind of January signing that changes a dressing room as much as it changes a team.
Jarrod Bowen – Hull City to West Ham United (2020)
£22m for a player who became a European trophy winner, a full England international, and eventually club captain. Bowen’s rise has been remarkable. He delivered the goal that won West Ham the UEFA Conference League, their first major trophy in over 40 years, and has been the heartbeat of the team ever since. A signing that reshaped the club’s identity and ambitions.
Khvicha Kvaratskhelia – Napoli to PSG (2025)
A modern example of a January signing who instantly changed everything. Kvaratskhelia arrived in Paris with huge expectations and somehow exceeded them, helping deliver PSG’s first Champions League title. His creativity, unpredictability, and ability to break open tight games gave PSG the dimension they’d been missing for years. A transformational signing in real time.
The Power of the January Window
January isn’t supposed to be a place for long‑term planning. It’s supposed to be a scramble, a patch‑up job, a gamble, a short‑term fix. But every so often, a club finds a player who doesn’t just fill a gap, they change the club’s future.
Semenyo might just be the next name on that list. If he helps Manchester City complete a historic quadruple, he’ll join a group of players who walked through the door in winter and left a legacy that lasted for years.
And that’s the beauty of January signings: You never quite know when a season, or a club, is about to be transformed.
FPL Gameweek 28’s Essential Fixtures & Players to Target
Last week’s team was a case of so near, yet so far, as 25 points were left on the bench.…
Tommy the Punter’s Midweek Moves: Leverkusen can complete Greek tragedy
It’s time to show my mettle, and this week we’re looking at some Champions League and Championship tips to help…
Stake Review
Stake has become one of the biggest and most recognisable names in global crypto betting, and with 38.8 million customers…